Sista Felicia’s Peeps Easter Egg Surprise




Sista Felicia’s Peeps Easter Egg Surprise

Time to start preparing sweet treats for Easter. Last year this recipe was created and posted on Sista’s Dish after being inspired by my favorite childhood Italian traditional Easter candy while shopping at Scalafini Bakery here in Gloucester. Its a fun recipe to make with kids and adults of all ages.

italian candy easter egg scalafini

Click Read more for Step-by-Step Recipe and photos


Sista Felicia’s Peeps Easter Egg Surprise

1 box white cake mix

¼ teaspoon-½ teaspoon teal, yellow, pink, purple, and green food coloring for coconut

1 lb. chocolate melts

2 bars Trader Joes The Dark Chocolate Lovers Chocolate Bar

3 cups white frosting

4 large Marshmallow Peeps Bunnies

2 cups coconut flakes; mixed with green food coloring

4 Lindt Chocolate Carrot

¼ cup Jelly Beans

large pastry bag fitted with large star tip

1 four section half Easter Egg Baking Pan


1  chill four section half Easter Egg Baking Pan in refrigerator 15 minutes; melt chocolates in double boiler pan

2 using pastry brush; coat each section with melted chocolate; chill 3 minutes

3  repeat step 2 until all chocolate is used; chill final coating of chocolate 15 minutes

4  fill small cereal bowl with warm water; dip bottom side of pan with chilled molded chocolate in bowl of warm water 10 seconds; gently tap pan on counter and remove chocolate egg from mold; repeat with remaining 3 chocolate egg molds in pan; chocolate eggs should stand freely; reserve chocolate eggs

*Note~ heat bottom of chocolate egg with candle lighter 5 seconds and fix standing straight on aluminum foil lined flat surface; hold in place until chocolate sets and egg stands freely)

5  mix cake batter according to box instruction; evenly divide batter into 4 separate bowls or large cups; mix one food coloring into each

6  fill ¾ of each Easter Egg section of baking pan, by layering each colored cake batter in each egg section; bake until fully cooked (follow box instruction for cupcakes for baking times)

7  remove cakes from pan; cool 10 minutes; cut puffy end of each egg off and discard cut ends

8   place cakes into chocolate Easter egg mold; pip each with white frosting using pastry bag fitted with large star tip

9   fix Marshmallow Peeps Bunny on top; sprinkle with green coconut flakes; and fasten jelly bean candies using white frosting; attach Lindt chocolate carrot candy to each  Peeps Bunny; serve


2 thoughts on “Sista Felicia’s Peeps Easter Egg Surprise

Leaving a comment rewards the author of this post- add to the discussion here-

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s